Your Pie Reviews
Your Pie has an overall rating of 4.4 based on 92 reviews. Customer feedback on Your Pie is mixed: Your Pie reviewers highlight positive aspects like customizable options, fresh ingredients, friendly service, quick delivery, which strongly appeal to health-conscious individuals, busy professionals, families looking for convenient meals. However, Your Pie is often criticized for its higher prices, limited locations, occasional order errors, inconsistent portion sizes.
92 reviews
5 Stars
23
4 Stars
0
3 Stars
3
2 Stars
4
1 Star
0
How would you rate Your Pie?
All Your Pie Reviews (92)
laurencemoore3367
May 17, 2026
"Finally Felt Safe Eating Out"
I have food allergies, so eating out can be stressful, especially when some places don’t seem to take it as seriously as they should. Here, though, the staff listened, answered my questions, and made me feel like they actually cared. It was such a relief to enjoy a meal without feeling on edge the whole time.
0
Reply
SanfordAyala
April 30, 2026
"Really liked it"
I’m not even sure what I was expecting, but I ended up really liking it. It just worked out well for me, and I’d probably go for it again.
0
Reply
casandra-Christian
April 27, 2026
"Good for a quick lunch"
It was worth it for a quick lunch. Nothing too fancy, but it hit the spot and was easy to grab when I didnt have much time. Would probbaly stop by again.
0
Reply
REED
April 25, 2026
"Prices Could Be Clearer"
The food was fine, but the pricing on Your Pie was a little confusing until I got close to checkout. Like, the extra toppings and fees didn’t really show up early enough, so it made comparing options kind of annoying. Not a huge deal, just something I wish was clearer up front.
0
Reply
BOOTH
April 24, 2026
"Great Variety for Everyone"
I really like how many options they have on the menu. There’s pizza, pasta, salads, tons of toppings, and even gluten-free choices, which I think is a big plus. It makes it easy to find something that works for everyone, and that kind of variety is definitely worth appreciating
0
Reply
Wesley_sanders97
April 16, 2026
"A Sweet Little Treat"
I had a feeling the dessert was going to be good as soon as it came out, and yep, it totally was. Super yummy and just hit the spot.
0
Reply
marissa_Hinkle02
April 15, 2026
"They’ve got some decent veggie options…"
They’ve got some decent veggie options, and you can obviously build a pizza without cheese if you’re vegan. That said, the vegan choices still feel limited. I’d expect at least a better range of toppings or a vegan cheese option these days. It’s fine if you just need something quick, but it’s not really anything special.
0
Reply
WATKINS
April 05, 2026
"Late order and no drink"
The order showed up late, and the weird part is my drink was missing too. I was already waiting longer than expected, so realizing part of my order wasn’t there made it even more frustrating...
0
Reply
Catherine.presha
April 04, 2026
"Easy Post-Soccer Dinner With the Kids"
Stopped in here with my kids after soccer, and it was a nice, low-stress choice. The staff were friendly, the kids had fun making their own pizzas, and I appreciated that nobody made us feel rushed. I’m usually a little cautious trying places with tired, hungry kids because things can go sideways fast, but this felt easy and comfortable
0
Reply
richard.Bowdry
March 25, 2026
"Easy place to relax and eat"
The vibe inside was super chill. It wasn’t loud at all, and I felt really comfortable eating there. For me, if a place is calm and cozy, that’s usually all I need to know I’ll come back
0
Reply
Jerome_felton92
March 22, 2026
"Really good gluten free crust !"
I tried the gluten free crust and really liked it . It tasted great , and I didn’t have any issues afterward
0
Reply
robert1976
March 16, 2026
"I was happy with how…"
I was happy with how much food I got. I even checked the email receipt after ordering because I thought the pizza might end up being smaller, but it was loaded and didn’t feel skimpy at all. It filled me up easily, and for the price, the portion size was solid. I’d definitely order it again
0
Reply
james1987
February 27, 2026
"Better drink selection than I expected"
I didn’t expect them to have that many drink options, but they did, and it went really well with my pizza. I blame myself for not checking the menu sooner because I probably would’ve tried something different a long time ago.
0
Reply
Theresa_lara86
February 26, 2026
"Pretty solid order overall"
Everything I ordered was there, and as far as I could tell, there weren’t any missing toppings or mix-ups. I was happy with it overall.
0
Reply
peggy2002
February 25, 2026
"Not gonna lie, I was impressed. The..."
Not gonna lie, I was impressed. The veggies tasted super fresh and the dough was nice and soft. Definitely something I’d order again.
0
Reply
misty-Seal
February 22, 2026
"Super Fast Pizza Run"
The service was really quick. I barely had time to settle in before the pizza was ready, which was kind of perfect because I was hungry. Also, the staff seemed on top of things, and yeah, the whole pickup was just easy and fast
0
Reply
Lynette_yang76
February 12, 2026
"Pizza was okay, but arrived cold"
The pizza tasted fine overall, but it showed up kind of cold and the cheese had already gone stiff, which was disappointing. I tried reaching out to support, but it felt like I was getting copy-paste replies that didn’t really address the issue. Not the best experience this time.
0
Reply
pamela_Southard88
February 07, 2026
"I keep coming back because I know…"
I keep coming back because I know exactly what I’m going to get every time. The pizza tastes consistent, the staff is usually friendly, and I don’t have to wait around forever, which I really appreciate. I haven’t had a bad experience here, so when I’m craving pizza and don’t want to overthink it, this is where I order from.
0
Reply
harrydarwish2757
February 01, 2026
"So relieved my order was ready fast"
I ordered from yourpie.com around lunchtime and expected to be stuck waiting forever since it looked busy. But I was pleasantly surprised, my food was ready way quicker than I thought it would be. Pickup was super easy, the wait was short, and I didn’t have that frustrating feeling of just standing around wondering what’s going on. It’s such a nice little relief when a place actually has your order ready close to the time they promised
0
Reply
bonnie1978
January 31, 2026
"Loved how customizable it was"
There were so many toppings to choose from, I almost felt like they were quietly tempting me to pile on way more than I planned. Not complaining though — I ended up making it exactly how I wanted, and it turned out really good.
0
Reply
Have a question about Your Pie?
Log in to ask your Your Pie question!
Customer Reviews
Ask a Question
